In this problem, I drew a picture and labeled the length 15 and the width 10. I then used the A=l x w formula and plugged in the numbers to get 150 sq. feet as the answer.
Fencing Task
With this problem, there was a little more work involved:
1- To get the greatest area, you would have to try all of the combinations that would give you 24 ft on the perimeter: 7x5, 6x6, 9x3, 8x4, and 10x2. Using the area formula for each one, you find that a pen that is 6x6 on each side gives you 36 sq. feet which is the most room.
2- Again, you have to look at all of the combinations that would give you 16 ft on the perimeter: 5x3, 6x2, 7x1, and 4x4. In this case the largest are is 16 sq ft, meaning each side would be 4 ft. long.
3- In both problems, the perfect squares yielded the greatest area in the pen. If you have an amount of fencing that you can not use a perfect square with, you can always draw a picture to figure it out.
Similarities: both problems are area problems, both require a prior knowledge of area and how to find it
Differences: the amount of thinking/reasoning required for each problem, the number of ways in which the problem can be solved, and the need to generalize,
Elementary Tasks
High Level Cognitive Demand
|
Low Level Cognitive Demand
|
Task A: interpret unit of measure
|
Task C: real life situation and solve
|
Task B: continuing patterns
|
Task D: respond to graph questions
|
Task F: fractions
|
Task E: place value
|
Task H: use graph to make predictions
|
Task G: solve division with calculator
|
Task M: interpret average (application)
|
Task I: multiplication
|
Task N: analysis
|
Task J: comprehension (explain)
|
Task P: application
|
Task K: comprehension (explain)
|
High levels of cognitive demand include: making connections, analyzing information, drawing conclusions, abstract thinking, and completing procedures (tasks) with connections to meaning
Low levels of cognitive demand include: stating facts, following procedures, solving routine problems, having single cognitive answers to a problem, and memorization with connections to meaning
Discussion
A. Does a particular feature (e.g., writing an explanation as part of your answer, drawing a picture to explain what you did, using manipulatives to solve the task) indicate that the task has a certain level of cognitive demand?
While I do not think because a task has a particular feature that it indicates a certain level of cognitive demand, high cognitive demand tasks requires students to make sense of them. They have to read, determine what the questions is and how to use the information provided in the task. There are often multiple ways of finding the correct answer(s) to the task. High cognitive demand questions invites students to explain their thinking, make new connections, describe their process of figuring out the answer, and/or critique other's ideas. Low level cognitive demand generally focuses on correct answers.
B. Is there a difference between "level of cognitive demand" and "difficulty"?
Yes. The level of cognitive demand describes the type of thinking required by a task, not whether the task is "difficult".
C. What effect does context (e.g., setting in which the task is used, students' prior experience, grade level) have on the level of cognitive demand required by a task?
The tasks in which students engage provide the contexts in which they learn to think about subject matter and different tasks may place differing cognitive demands on students. There is a connection with how the question is written, how it is presented and how it is implemented that will have an effect on the cognitive demand.